Alex Payne (who I respect and read obsessively) wrote a critique of the iPad on his blog here that I recommend reading before I continue… I’ll wait.
Okay, now that you’ve read the article, I can say that I don’t really agree. I don’t see the iPad as a hit against creators or the death of tinkering. For me, personally, the iPad compares to the other “consumer” devices in my house: TV, DVD Player, Kindle, etc.; except, the iPad is more creative-friendly than any of those options. Let’s face it, I love my TV and DVD collection as a consumer, but they haven’t brought me any closer or further away from becoming a director. I consume tons of books on my Kindle, and the fact that I’m not a published author has never been a setback (although I can dream). I firmly believe that everybody is a creator in some ways (even my mechanic), and they end up being consumers in other places (like my and my TV). I think the iPad encourages creation on two levels that those never can, though; it encourages interaction, and it sets a mark that I, as a creator, can reach.
Most of the apps that that I use daily on my iPhone (Tweetie, Facebook, WordPress, etc.) are actually built for interaction. They are not built for pure consumption. Of course, I understand that’s not really what Alex meant, but I still think it puts the iPad one step ahead of most consumer devices that it is really replacing.
More important than the apps, though, the iPad gives me a target that I can actually achieve as a creator: the web. I savor the idea that a website I build (without Flash, obviously) can be used more places than just a desk. With one deft move by Apple, all of my creations as a web developer have become mobile experiences without always having to squeeze onto a tiny screen. I understand the frustration by some developers, but I’m honestly still excited working in the most “open” development field available today: the web.
Like I said, I respect Alex Payne (and I recommend reading everything he writes), but I don’t see the iPad as a harbinger of a soul-less dystopia. Honestly, the moment that computers left the hobby clubs and entered the homes, they became consumer devices for 90% of their users. I see this as an impetus for the next generation of creatives to get out there and make something for all the single moms, non-techies, and baby boomer parents that might be using this “new class” more than traditional computers.
Finally, this has nothing to do with Alex, but I have no opinion on whether any single person can, could, or should get the iPad. Since I haven’t even seen it in person, this is obviously not a review. If the iPad doesn’t do everything you’ve ever dreamed, you don’t have to buy it. I really won’t be offended. Personally, I still dream of getting one for myself (to replace the Kindle and the practice of squeezing all my newsfeed and web reading onto the iPhone) and my wife (who has an iMac that, while powerful, has never been portable).
We launched the official Vintage 56 blog over at MarketingDilemma.com this week. It’s based on Basic Maths by Khoi Vinh, and has just enough tweaks right now to make me happy that it’s not totally stock. Honestly, I think they started with a template this time around to keep me from fiddling too much and just launch it by the end of the week.
